My Unpopular Bookish Opinions

Apr 15, 2025

—

Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly bookish meme hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl. It provides book enthusiasts with a fresh topic each week to discuss and share on Tuesdays, bringing the book-loving community together.

This week we are diving into unpopular bookish opinions. This is going to be a fun week with reading everyone’s unpopular opinions. I feel like I don’t have too many unpopular bookish opinions but I will share some of the ones I do have 🙂

Too Many “Special” Editions

So, every book that comes out now is a “special” edition? At this point, they don’t seem all that special anymore. Not every book that is released now needs sprayed edges.

I hate bonus chapters/epilogues

Not going to lie… I skim these. I cannot deal with all the extra stuff authors think we need at the end of books.

BookTok is not a healthy place

I honestly don’t care for BookTok. I feel like it’s not a good platform and it’s not a safe place for readers. I feel like there are a lot of bullies over there. Although, I am thankful that BookTok really made reading popular again. I loved seeing so many people find reading and learned that they do enjoy it!

Shaming people for liking certain books is not okay

If someone reads a book you didn’t like, it’s not okay to shame them for it. If someone reads a book from an author you don’t like, it’s not okay to shame them for it. And the other way around if they don’t like books you like and authors you like.

What are your unpopular bookish opinions?

Top Ten Tuesday

Comments

21 responses to “My Unpopular Bookish Opinions”

damppebbles

April 15, 2025

I agree with so many of these. I haven’t dared brave booktok. Not sure it’s for me 😂 Thanks for visiting.

https://damppebbles.com/2025/04/15/toptentuesday-15th-april-2025/

Reply
1. Tiffany
  
  April 15, 2025
  
  Don’t bother with it! It’s honestly an addicting app and I’d rather spend time reading than doom scrolling.
  
  Reply
stefani

April 15, 2025

I’m not a fan of bonus chapters either. https://readwithstefani.com/my-unpopular-bookish-opinions/

Reply
Laurie

April 15, 2025

I totally agree about Booktok! I never liked it, not even when it was brand new. I read most hypes (ACOTAR, A Little Life, Evelyn Hugo, It Ends With Us) way before it already. I also agree on th special editions.

My TTT: https://laurieisreading.com/2025/04/15/top-ten-tuesday-books-on-my-tbr-i-avoid-reading-and-why/

Reply
lydiaschoch

April 15, 2025

To each their own, but I do not understand the special edition trend.

Reply
Shoto

April 15, 2025

I agree with all of these! The BookTok one is a bit nuancced because I do like that reading is becoming popular but some people on there are really bullies lol. And big YES for the special editions! Why does every book need to have sprayed edges?? Feels like a money grab.

Reply
lindseyreads

April 15, 2025

I agree about the special editions! Yes, they’re pretty but a lot of the times it just feels like a money grab.

Reply
Rissi

April 15, 2025

OHMYGOSH! I have been formulating a “discussion” post in my mind about how things aren’t “special” or unique anymore (going beyond just books), so your line “At this point, they don’t seem all that special anymore” is one I really relate to! So true. 🙂 Thanks so much for visiting my list.

Reply
Leslie

April 15, 2025

Yes!! The amount of special editions is getting out of hand. Now, there’s several per book and it’s not even special anymore. I’m actually over it. lol

Reply
Dini @ dinipandareads

April 15, 2025

If these are unpopular opinions then I fully share them with you! 😂 I have to admit that I love special editions a lot but I feel like they’re no longer special because there are so many coming out. Yet, with so many being produced by every company and all the book boxes, I still feel like it’s a cutthroat competition to get your hands on one?! Sometimes the book community can be pretty wild, lol.

Reply
Pam @ Read! Bake! Create!

April 15, 2025

These opinions aren’t all that unpopular in my mind. While I’ve never been on BookTok, I have seen lots of people saying it’s repetative and adds nothing new to the bookish community because everyone is reading the same books and loving everything about them. Special editions are nice to look at, but if every book is getting that treatment, all the time, how special is it really?
Pam @ Read! Bake! Create!
https://readbakecreate.com/books-that-dont-deserve-the-hype-my-unpopular-opinon/

Reply
Sophie @BewareOfTheReader

April 15, 2025

Booktok is not healthy and shaming people! I totally agree with these!

Reply
Haze

April 15, 2025

I contemplated downloading Tiktok in the early days of Booktok because I wondered what the hype was about, now I’m glad I didn’t. I definitely agree about not shaming people for liking/not liking books. I’d still feel sad if someone didn’t like a book I loved, but obviously we all have different tastes and that’s totally okay!

Haze
https://thebookhaze.com/

Reply
Bree @1girl2manybooks

April 16, 2025

I agree with your points! I have plenty of books I don’t like but I think that ultimately, people should read what THEY like… I also stay off BookTok, I think I’m too old or something for all that, lol. Although in terms of special editions, I disagree there but only because they’ve only just started being available here, lol. I think our market was too small to make it worthwhile but now with the popularity of certain books (Fourth Wing basically) we’ve started getting a few. But if I were in the US or UK where there’s quite a few exclusive and special editions of many books, I’d prob feel the same.

Reply
Lauren Always Me

April 16, 2025

I’m fine with epilogues, but bonus content I can take or leave.

Reply
Marwah @ The Booklore Fairy

April 16, 2025

I agree 100% with the special editions opinion! I never buy them, apart from the occasional classic, but they are way too many nowadays, and they’re always super expensive.

If you’d like to visit, here’s my TTT: https://thebooklorefairyreads.wordpress.com/2025/04/15/top-ten-tuesday-unpopular-bookish-opinions/

Reply
TNT

April 17, 2025

I agree with not shaming people for their reading choices/tastes. I just say “that’s a joy I leave to others”.

I will respectfully disagree on the bonus chapter/epilogue issue; if it’s an author I enjoy, more is better and I like a leisurely ending (though I’ve never been required to preorder from a special website or subscribe to a particular service to get that bonus).

Thanks for the list and happy reading!

Reply
Aj @ Read All The Things!

April 17, 2025

I agree about epilogues. I think a lot of them are unnecessary, especially the marriage/baby ones. It’s like the character can’t be happy without a man and a baby.

Reply
1. Leah’s Books
  
  April 18, 2025
  
  THIS!!!!!
  
  Reply
Leah’s Books

April 18, 2025

We really have a lot of opinions in common this week! The one that stood out to me the most was about Booktok not being a safe place for readers. I started an account a year or two ago, and shared how I didn’t like Zodiac Academy, and I got PILED ON by bullies who aren’t willing to accept valid criticism about a book they love. It’s got a huge number of views though, and people still comment on it! But Booktok wasn’t a safe place for me because I’d get a mix of toxic fandoms and antisemitism, so I pretty much abandoned the account, just use it to see funny things my friends send me.

Reply
April ’25 Wrap Up – Romantasy Life

May 1, 2025

[…] Review: The Sinner by Shantel TessierThe Sunday Post #1Book Review: Runaway Love by Melanie HarlowTop Ten Tuesday: My Unpopular Bookish OpinionsLet’s Talk Bookish: Favorite Bookish AccessoriesBook Tag: 2025 Quarter Year […]

Reply